Hire a freelancer when you want the person doing the work to be the person you speak to, and when the account needs judgement rather than headcount. Hire an agency when you need several disciplines at once, cover for holidays and illness, or spend large enough to justify a team. Most eCommerce accounts under roughly £200,000 a month are better served by one experienced person.
An agency sells capacity. That is a real thing to buy: several specialists, cover when someone is away, and a process that does not collapse when one person leaves. For a business running paid search, paid social, SEO and CRO at once, that is worth paying for.
What it is not selling you, despite the pitch deck, is the senior person who won the account. The person who impressed you in the meeting is rarely the person logging into your account on a Tuesday. That work usually sits with an executive managing a portfolio of accounts, working from a checklist, because the economics of agency retainers require it.
That is not a scandal. It is arithmetic. A fee has to cover the account manager, the strategist, the exec, the tools and the overheads. What is left for the actual work is a slice of one junior person's week.
A freelancer sells judgement and attention. Fewer clients, direct access, and the person building the account is the person you argue with about it.
The genuine risks are worth naming. One person gets ill, takes holidays and can be hit by a bus. One person cannot cover paid search, paid social, SEO and email properly, whatever their website says. And a freelancer who takes on too many clients is simply a worse agency with none of the cover.
The way to test it is blunt: ask how many accounts they run and who else touches yours.
Ask either one this: what is my cost of goods, and what does a sale actually leave behind?
If the answer is vague, the account is being run on revenue and ROAS, which is what Google reports rather than what you are paid. That is true of plenty of freelancers and plenty of agencies. It is the question that sorts them, not the business model.
Push it one step further and ask about unit economics and customer economics. Very few will have an answer. Some will talk about “margin”, which is the easier question wearing the same coat — a headline margin ignores fulfilment, payment fees and returns, and says nothing about what a customer is worth after the first order. Contribution margin covers the first half of that, and lifetime value the second.
Follow it with: what would you stop spending on tomorrow, and why? Anyone who has genuinely looked at the account will have an answer ready.
Roughly, and from experience rather than a survey:
The wrong reason to pick an agency is that it feels safer. The wrong reason to pick a freelancer is that it is cheaper. Both are decisions about who does the thinking.
Usually, but that is not the argument for one. A freelancer carries less overhead, so more of the fee goes into the work rather than into account management. If you are choosing purely on price you will end up with someone running too many accounts, which costs more than the saving.
This is the real weakness and it should be asked about directly. Smart bidding means accounts do not need daily intervention, but something can still go wrong. Ask what cover exists, how quickly they respond, and what happens if a feed breaks while they are away.
Up to a point. Large accounts are not harder per pound, they are harder in breadth: more markets, more feeds, more stakeholders. One person can run a large single-market account well, and will struggle with a multi-market, multi-channel programme. Ask where their limit is and be suspicious if they say there isn't one.
Not sure where your budget is going?A free Google Ads audit, written down and walked through on a screenshare. You keep the findings either way.
Request an auditThirty minutes, no obligation and no sales script. If I am not the right fit I will say so on the call and point you somewhere better.
I will reply within one working day. If you would rather not wait, pick a time that suits you now.
Book a time now30 minutes, no obligation.