Cameron
Jackson
Google Ads · Profit-led
Home › How should subscription brands run Google Ads?

How should subscription brands run Google Ads?

Bid on expected subscription value inside a payback window rather than on the first order, because a first charge rarely covers acquisition. Send a churn-adjusted value, exclude existing subscribers from acquisition campaigns, and judge the account on new subscribers and retained cohorts rather than on the ROAS Google reports.

The first order is not the product

In a subscription business the first charge is a sample of the revenue, not the revenue. Bidding to first-order ROAS therefore sets acquisition budgets from the smallest number in the model, and the account will always look like it is failing.

This is why subscription brands with healthy retention frequently have paid search that appears unprofitable. The account is being judged on one twelfth of what it produced.

Which value to send

Not the first charge, and not the full projected lifetime either. Send the contribution you expect within a payback window you can finance, adjusted for churn.

  • Take average contribution per delivery or per month, after cost of goods, fulfilment and payment fees
  • Multiply by the number of periods you genuinely retain, from cohort data rather than an average
  • Discount it for uncertainty, then use that as the conversion value

Cohorts matter more than averages here. An average tenure of eight months made up of many one-month cancellations and a few two-year loyalists is a very different business from one where everyone stays eight months.

Trials and discounted first boxes

Heavily discounted first orders are the standard subscription acquisition tactic and they wreck conversion values if sent at face value. A £1 first box reported as £1 of revenue teaches Google that these customers are worthless.

Send the expected value of the subscription that the trial leads to, discounted by trial-to-paid conversion rate. If half of trials convert and a converted subscriber is worth £90 in the payback window, a trial is worth about £45, not £1.

Keep existing subscribers out of acquisition

Existing subscribers search your brand. If they are converting through acquisition campaigns, the numbers are inflated and you are paying to retain people you already have.

Separate brand from generic, exclude subscriber lists from acquisition campaigns as an audience exclusion, and use new customer acquisition reporting so you can see which campaigns bring genuinely new subscribers.

What to report on

New subscribers, nCAC, payback period and retained cohorts. Reported ROAS in a subscription account is close to meaningless in isolation, because the value being sent is a forecast rather than a fact.

The question that matters each month is simple: how many new subscribers, at what cost, and are last quarter's cohorts still here.

Common questions

Should I send the first charge or the subscription value?

The churn-adjusted subscription value within your payback window. Sending the first charge understates the customer so badly that bidding will throttle acquisition. Sending full lifetime value overstates it and burns cash.

How do I handle free trials in conversion tracking?

Fire the conversion at trial start, with a value equal to expected subscription value multiplied by your trial-to-paid rate. Firing only on the first paid charge delays the signal by weeks, which starves smart bidding of data when it most needs it.

Is Performance Max suitable for subscription brands?

Yes, provided it is fed the right value and given a new customer acquisition goal. Without those it will optimise towards the cheapest signups it can find, which in subscription almost always means the ones that churn fastest.

Not sure where your budget is going?A free Google Ads audit, written down and walked through on a screenshare. You keep the findings either way.

Request an audit

Still spending more than the account gives back?

Thirty minutes, no obligation and no sales script. If I am not the right fit I will say so on the call and point you somewhere better.

  • You work with me directly, throughout.
  • A fixed fee, never a share of your spend.
  • Reporting on the numbers that pay your bills.

Start the conversation

A thirty-minute call, with no obligation

Your details are used only to reply to you.

Thank you

I will reply within one working day. If you would rather not wait, pick a time that suits you now.

Book a time now

30 minutes, no obligation.